He said: I agree.
He said: in retrospect.
I looked at the kitten.
She had made a small sound.
A very small sound.
The sound of something very new.
I said: how old is she.
He said: the vet thinks four weeks.
He said: maybe four and a half.
He said: they were guessing.
I said: you took her to a vet.
He said: yesterday.
He said: I told them she was a stray I’d found.
He said: which is true.
He said: they said she’s healthy.
He said: she needed worming and a vaccination schedule.
He said: I have the papers in the garage.
I said: you have papers.
He said: documentation.
He said: from the vet.
He said: in case you had questions.
I looked at him.
He said: I thought you might have questions.
He said: you usually do.
He said: so I wanted to have answers.
The kitten made another sound.
I looked at her.
She looked at me.
She was entirely not afraid.
This was not bravado.
She was simply too young to have learned fear yet.
She was in the world and the world, in her experience, had been David’s hands and the garage and the vet’s office and whatever small amount of the outside she had seen.
She had been alone under the back steps for enough time that a cat might have given up.
She had not given up.
She looked like she had no intention of giving up.
I said: what were you going to name her.
David looked at me.
He said: I hadn’t.
He said: I thought that should probably be a joint decision.
I said: that is possibly the first jointly made decision of this entire situation.
He said: yes.
He said: I know.
He said: Ellen.
I said: yes.
He said: I should have told you.
He said: I was wrong to handle it the way I handled it.
He said: I know that you’ll be the one managing most of this.
He said: the feeding schedule and the vet appointments and the things that require coordination.
He said: and I should have included you from the beginning.
He said: instead of making the decision first and trying to present you with a fait accompli.
He said: that wasn’t respectful.
He said: I know that.
I said: yes.
He said: I’m sorry.
I said: yes.
I said: David.
He said: yes.
I said: why did you want to keep her.
He was quiet for a moment.
He said: she was alone.
He said: she was too small.
He said: she needed something.
He said: and I was the person who was there.
He said: so.
He said: I stayed.
I held the cat.
He told me the rest of it.
The first day.
He had been in the backyard putting away tools in the late afternoon.
He had heard something.
Not obviously a cat sound.
A small sound.
He had followed it under the back steps.
She was there.
In the space between the concrete base of the steps and the foundation of the house.
Too small.
Alone.
He had gone back inside and waited.
He had watched from the kitchen window.
Nothing had come.
No mother cat.
No movement in the yard.
At nine that evening he had gone back out.
She was still there.
She was cold.
He had picked her up and brought her into the garage.
He had put a box together with an old fleece blanket.
He had looked up what to feed a kitten too young to be without a mother.
He had gone to the pet store at nine-thirty and bought kitten milk replacer and a bottle.
He had read about how to feed her and how often and what temperature the milk should be.
He had done this research in the garage on his phone while she slept in the box.
He had set an alarm for every two hours.
He had gotten up and gone to the garage every two hours for the first night.
He had slept in the car for part of the second night because the walking back and forth woke me.
He said: I heard you turn over.
He said: I thought you heard me.
I said: you slept in the car.
He said: the back seat is adequate.
He said: for a few hours.
I said: David.
He said: yes.
I said: you slept in the back seat of the car so you could feed a kitten every two hours without waking me.
He said: it seemed like the most efficient solution at the time.
I said: and after the car.
He said: she was doing better.
He said: she was eating well.
He said: and she was getting through longer stretches.
He said: so I could check on her less often.
He said: that was when I thought about switching sides.
He said: if I was on the door side, I could move more quietly.
He said: I was right about that part.
He said: the execution was flawed.
I said: because I noticed.
He said: because you notice everything.
He said: I have known this about you for twenty years.
He said: I don’t know why I thought this time would be different.
I said: what did you think you were going to do.
He said: get her to eight weeks.
He said: show you.
He said: ask if we could keep her.
I said: and if I had said no.
He said: I had been thinking about that.
He said: I thought I could take her to a rescue.
He said: a good one.
He said: where I had verified the conditions.
He said: and she would be adopted.
He said: into a good home.
He said: I had found two that I thought were reputable.
I said: you found rescue organizations.
He said: as contingency planning.
He said: yes.
He said: in case.
I looked at him.
I had been married to this man for seventeen years.
I had been with him for twenty.
I knew him well enough to know the specific way he moved through problems.
He was an engineer.
He designed systems.
He identified problems and mapped solutions.
He stress-tested the solutions.
He had contingency plans.
He had applied all of this to a four-week-old kitten under the back steps.
He had not slept.
He had bought kitten formula.
He had set alarms.
He had slept in the car.
He had switched sides of the bed.
He had researched rescue organizations.
He had done all of this without telling me because he had thought he could handle it and present me with the outcome rather than the process.
Because he thought I would say no to the process.
Because he had not trusted that I would understand.
I said: David.
He said: yes.
I said: do you really think I would have said no.
He was quiet.
He said: I thought you might.
He said: you are organized.
He said: you think about what we can manage.
He said: you plan ahead.
He said: a kitten is not in the plan.
I said: a kitten under our back steps is not the same as deciding to get a kitten.
He said: I know that now.
He said: I think I know it then too.
He said: but I was afraid.
I said: of what.
He said: that you would say it was impractical.
He said: and you would be right.
He said: and I would have to give her to the rescue.
He said: and I didn’t want to do that.
He said: so I thought if I could get her far enough.
He said: past the part where it was just impractical.
He said: to the part where she was okay.
He said: the impractical part would be over.
He said: and then I could ask.
He said: about the part that was left.
He said: which is just.
He said: keeping her.
I said: David.
He said: yes.
I said: why did you want to keep her specifically.
He said: I told you. She was alone.
I said: lots of animals are alone. You’ve seen them. You haven’t brought them all home.
He was quiet.
He said: she looked at me.
He said: when I found her.
He said: under the steps.
He said: she looked at me and she didn’t run.