It was smaller than the nail on my little finger, with two curved edges joining at a point.

It resembled a tiny heart sketched in pencil.

I released her hair before moving it aside once more.

“Is that what I hadn’t seen?”

Mason nodded.

His mother continued calling his name through the phone until he told her he’d ring back.

“I saw a little pink at the hospital, Sandra.”

He lowered himself onto the highest stair.

“Right after the nurse gave her back to you.”

“Why didn’t you look then?”

He examined the step beneath him.

“I knew what it might look like.”

I waited for an explanation.

Keeping one hand against the railing, he finally murmured:

“Anna had one.”

I’d never heard that name before.

I carried Charlotte to her bassinet.

While unpacking earlier, I’d placed the little hair tie beside the lotion.

Without the mirror, the bedroom wall looked strangely incomplete.

Mason entered holding his phone and began searching through photographs, scrolling past several Christmas celebrations.

Eventually, an image appeared.

A woman was sitting with an infant stretched across her lap.

Although most of her face wasn’t visible, I recognized Margaret’s hands.

She was lifting the infant’s hair, revealing a birthmark practically identical to Charlotte’s.

“I took that picture of her baby book,” Mason said.

“Mom let me go through it once.”

I moved to the following photograph.

It showed another page from the same book, dated five years afterward.

Margaret was sitting alone, clutching an old teddy bear. Beside her picture, someone had attached a transparent plastic sleeve containing a lock of dark hair.

“When was this taken?”

Mason lowered his phone.

“After Anna died.”

The forgotten toaster clicked downstairs, but he remained with me.

I asked how old he’d been when it happened.

“Seven.”

Using both hands, he placed his phone down.

“She was going to trim Anna’s hair that morning.”

His gaze traveled toward the vacant hooks above the dresser.

“She’d put a comb out the night before.”

Mason remembered sitting on his parents’ mattress, knocking his heels against the wooden bed frame.

Anna had been standing on a small stool in front of the dresser while Margaret brushed her hair.

She smiled at her reflection.

Mason scrambled across the bedding to join them, and Margaret crouched until their three faces appeared together in the mirror.

“Mom just stood there watching her.”

His hands gradually relaxed.

“She said she’d finish the haircut after breakfast.”

Once breakfast was over, Anna climbed back onto the stool.

Margaret had scarcely begun when a yellow butterfly caught her daughter’s attention.

Laughing, Anna hopped down and raced toward the staircase.

Her mother hurried behind her, but Anna was quicker.

The screen door hadn’t been properly secured that morning.

Anna pushed it open and continued chasing the butterfly outdoors.

Hearing the door, Margaret rushed after her.

However, Anna had already reached the road.

An approaching driver applied the brakes but was unable to stop quickly enough.

Anna passed away in the hospital that afternoon.

The comb stayed where Margaret had originally placed it, and afterward, she repeatedly returned it to that exact location.

Eventually, she requested a small section of Anna’s hair.

It was the only portion of the planned haircut she’d ever receive.

“Did she always warn you about mirrors?”

Mason shook his head.

“That rule came later.”

He looked toward the empty space above our dresser.

“She built that belief around Anna’s final morning.”

Margaret had regularly brushed Mason’s hair before school.

One morning, he’d wondered aloud whether Anna’s hair would have become curly.

His mother paused with the comb hovering beside his ear. When he turned toward her, she set it down and walked away.

Gradually, Mason learned that mentioning his sister was something to avoid.

“Even with me?” I asked.

“With you, I could go days without thinking about it.”

I considered the six years we’d spent together.

There had been countless opportunities for him to tell me about Anna.

I would have listened as we sorted laundry or traveled home together.

There had always been room for her memory in our marriage.

Before contacting Margaret, we telephoned the hospital to inquire about Charlotte’s mark.

The pediatrician reviewed our daughter’s newborn examination records and confirmed she’d documented a common, harmless birthmark.

“Taking down the mirrors was your decision,” I said.

NEXT PART 3